The wide receiver situation in Miami is a little different this year. In 2008, we had a slew of no-names and unproven bodies. In 2009 the addition of two draftees in Brian Hartline and Patrick Turner added into the mix of a high-expectation 3rd year Ted Ginn Jr, and the proven but injured Greg Camarillo and the upstart Davone Bess to go with all the undrafted free agents and developmental players like Anthony Armstrong, Brandon London, etc.
This year we have a decidedly different first look.
We have a #1 WR in Brandon Marshall - you can't even use the word 'upgrade' here as it's sort of like trading in a standard definition television for an IMAX theater.
We have the fast growth and experienced sophomore player in Brian Hartline.
We have the year-separated-from-injury Camarillo. Though is butt may be a bit sore after his ridiculous catch vs Atlanta last year, his knee should be fine by now.
We have the 3rd year slot guy in Davone Bess, who has led the team in catches the past two seasons.
And we have 3 developmental players in Julius Pruitt, Taurus Johnson, and Patrick Turner - all three have significant Dolphins scout team experience under their belts.
Add to the 7 above, the large target, Roberto Wallace, the speedy Marlon Moore, and the reliable Ryan Grice-Mullen, and you see a very definite plan here as far as competition and positioning goes:
You have your big targets:
Brandon Marshall: 6'4", 230 lbs
Patrick Turner: 6'5", 220 lbs
Roberto Wallace: 6'4", 225 lbs
You have your shifty slot guys:
Davone Bess: 5'10", 190 lbs
Ryan Grice-Mullen: 5'11", 180 lbs
Marlon Moore: 6'00", 190 lbs
You have your reliable intermediate guys:
Brian Hartline: 6'2", 186 lbs
Greg Camarillo: 6'1", 190 lbs
Taurus Johnson: 6'1", 205 lbs
Julius Pruitt: 6'2", 206 lbs
Due to need, it's likely that Miami will end up with 6 WRs on the team (it seems obvious to me they are trying to lower the number of offensive linemen they will need to keep and they will likely reduce the number of defensive backs, thus allowing for an extra WR and extra LB - keep in mind they will likely cut one once Jason Ferguson is eligible to return).
I would expect them to keep only one of the smaller receivers as an intermediate player could also play the slot, or they could line up with fewer 3 WR formations should, say Bess, go down to injury. And I don't see more than 2 of the bigger targets being kept.
With that in mind, here are some possible scenarios for opening day 2010:
SCENARIO 1:
SCENARIO 2:
SCENARIO 3:
SCENARIO 4: